The Honourable Member
Story Summary
In this captivating moral tale, a member of the Legislature, who had vowed not to steal, returns home with a large part of the Capitol dome, inciting his constituents to hold an indignation meeting and consider punishment. Defending himself by claiming he never promised not to lie, he is oddly deemed an "honourable man" and elected to Congress without any pledges, showcasing the humorous yet educational nature of short moral stories.
Click to reveal the moral of the story
The story illustrates the idea that integrity and honesty in public service are essential, as mere compliance with legal obligations can still lead to moral corruption.
Historical Context
This story reflects the satirical tradition of political commentary prevalent in American literature, drawing on the legacy of figures like Jonathan Swift and Mark Twain, who criticized political corruption and the moral failings of public officials. The absurdity of the situation, where a legislator is rewarded despite blatant dishonesty, echoes the disillusionment with politics in the late 19th and early 20th centuries, as well as the broader theme of the often tenuous relationship between elected officials and their constituents. Such tales serve as a reflection of societal cynicism toward governance and the complexities of political ethics.
Our Editors Opinion
This story reflects the ongoing struggle between public trust and political accountability in modern life, highlighting how elected officials can manipulate ethical boundaries for personal gain. A real-life scenario could involve a politician who, despite campaigning on a platform of transparency and integrity, engages in deceptive practices—such as misusing campaign funds—while justifying their actions with legal loopholes, ultimately eroding public trust and accountability.
You May Also Like
The Mourning Brothers
In the short story "The Mourning Brothers," an Old Man, sensing his death, challenges his sons to prove their sorrow by wearing weeds on their hats, promising his fortune to the one who endures the longest. After years of stubbornness, they agree to share the inheritance, only to discover that an Executor has taken control of the estate, leaving them with nothing. This tale, rich in folklore and moral lessons, highlights the consequences of hypocrisy and obstinacy, making it one of the best moral stories in short story collections.
The Fox and the Bramble
In "The Fox and the Bramble," a fox climbs a hedge but falls and grabs a bramble for support, only to be pricked and hurt. Accusing the bramble of being more harmful than the hedge, he learns that he should have expected pain from something that also causes it to others. This wisdom-packed moral story illustrates how selfish individuals often encounter selfishness in others, a common theme in well-known moral stories.
A Fatal Disorder
In "A Fatal Disorder," a dying man, shot and on the verge of death, confesses to the District Attorney that he was the aggressor in the altercation, defying the typical narrative of self-defense found in many well-known moral stories. His unexpected honesty leaves officials stunned, as they are more accustomed to distorted dying declarations, highlighting the value-based moral lessons often present in simple moral stories. As the Police Surgeon humorously notes, it is the truth itself that is ultimately killing him, underscoring the weight of accountability in these short tales with moral implications.
Other names for this story
"Capitol Conundrum", "The Lying Legislator", "Promises and Politics", "Dome of Deceit", "Honour Among Thieves", "The Unpledged Politician", "A Member's Dilemma", "Feathers and Folly"
Did You Know?
This story satirizes the often blurred lines between ethics and morality in politics, highlighting how voters may overlook dishonesty if it serves their interests, suggesting that the promise to not steal is easily overshadowed by the acceptance of a politician's ability to lie.
Subscribe to Daily Stories
Get a new moral story in your inbox every day.