The Judge and the Plaintiff
Story Summary
In this captivating moral story, a businessman awaits a court ruling against a railway company and, in a moment of levity, offers to split the potential damages with the judge. However, the judge, realizing his mistake, reveals that he has already ruled in the plaintiff's favor, prompting the businessman to retract his offer and express gratitude instead. This simple moral story highlights the importance of integrity and honesty in the face of temptation.
A man of experience in business was awaiting the judgment of the court in a lawsuit he had brought against a railway company for damages. As he sat there, the door opened, and the judge entered the courtroom.
"Well," said the judge, "I am going to decide your case today. If I should rule in your favor, I wonder how you would express your satisfaction?"
"Sir," replied the man of experience in business, "I would risk your anger by offering you one half of the sum awarded."
"Did I say I was going to decide that case?" the judge responded abruptly, as if awakening from a daydream. "Dear me, how absent-minded I am. I mean, I have already decided it, and judgment has been entered for the full amount you sued for."
"Did I say I would give you one half?" the man of experience in business said coldly. "Dear me, how close I came to being a rascal. What I meant to say is that I am greatly obliged to you."
Click to reveal the moral of the story
The story illustrates the idea that one's true character is revealed through their reactions to unexpected circumstances, highlighting the importance of integrity and honesty.
Historical Context
This story reflects the themes of legal absurdity and moral ambiguity often found in satirical literature, reminiscent of works like those of Jonathan Swift and Charles Dickens, who critiqued societal and judicial systems of their time. The dialogue showcases a cultural context where the legal profession and business ethics are scrutinized, illustrating the tension between personal gain and integrity, a motif prevalent in early 20th-century literature and folklore. The story bears similarities to fables and moral tales that convey lessons about honesty and the potential pitfalls of greed, echoing the narrative tradition of using wit to highlight human folly.
Our Editors Opinion
This story highlights the importance of integrity and the moral dilemmas we face in the pursuit of success, reminding us that ethical behavior should prevail over the temptation to exploit opportunities for personal gain. In modern life, a scenario reflecting this moral could involve an employee who discovers a loophole in company policy that could allow them to take credit for a coworker's project; instead of taking the easy path, they choose to acknowledge their colleague's contributions, thereby fostering a culture of trust and collaboration in the workplace.
You May Also Like
A Talisman
In the short bedtime story "A Talisman," a Prominent Citizen tries to evade jury duty by submitting a physician's certificate claiming he suffers from softening of the brain. The Judge humorously dismisses his excuse, stating that he indeed possesses a brain, highlighting the importance of fulfilling civic responsibilities. This thought-provoking moral story serves as a valuable lesson for young readers about accountability and the futility of trying to avoid one's duties.
The Man with No Enemies
In "The Man with No Enemies," an inoffensive person is brutally assaulted by a stranger, leading to a trial where he claims to have no enemies. The defendant argues that this lack of enemies was the very reason for the attack, prompting the judge to dismiss the case with a humorous yet moral lesson: a person without enemies cannot truly have friends, and thus should not seek justice in court. This short story serves as a thought-provoking moral lesson for students about the complexities of relationships and the nature of conflict.
The Man and His Two Sweethearts
In this entertaining moral story, a middle-aged man courts two women—a younger one seeking youthfulness and an older one embarrassed by their age difference. Their attempts to modify his appearance lead to a comical outcome, as both women pull out all of his hair, leaving him completely bald. The tale serves as a simple moral story illustrating that trying to please everyone can ultimately result in losing everything.
Other names for this story
Judgment Day, The Courtroom Conundrum, Verdict Unveiled, Justice Served, The Businessman's Dilemma, The Unexpected Ruling, A Case of Misunderstanding, The Generous Plaintiff
Did You Know?
This story highlights the theme of ethics in business and the often precarious relationship between legal decisions and personal integrity, illustrating how a moment of temptation can reveal one's true character. The humorous exchange between the businessman and the judge underscores the absurdity of trying to undercut justice while simultaneously showcasing the importance of honesty.
Subscribe to Daily Stories
Get a new moral story in your inbox every day.